Part of the LIMS software guide
Method · Control plan

Raw material incoming inspection: a 5-step method.

Documents, sensory check, test reports, decision, record: the method to organise incoming inspection and make it readable at audit, batch by batch.

Incoming inspection is the check, at the time of delivery, that the raw material received matches the order, the requirements defined by the manufacturer and the documents accompanying the batch - before it enters stock or production. This page describes a method for organising it, documenting it and making it readable at audit: what is checked, in what order, on which documents, and how the acceptance decision is taken and kept. It is aimed at food manufacturers who receive raw materials and must decide on their acceptance based on their own requirements and the supplier's documents, not at the testing laboratory, which carries out the tests.

Key points
  • Incoming inspection is judged on its written decision rule, not on the number of checks carried out.
  • Five steps structure it: document check, sensory and physical check, test report review, acceptance decision, record.
  • Each supplier document must be linked to a decision: acceptance, conditional acceptance, hold, rejection.
  • Matching a test report or certificate of analysis against internal requirements relies on a written grid: parameter, threshold, method, limit of quantification, unit and basis of expression.
  • Concessions and non-conformities at goods-in are traced decisions, taken by the quality teams, never informal arrangements.

What does incoming inspection cover, and where does it stop?

Incoming inspection checks that a delivery matches the order and the written requirements, in terms of its condition, its documents and, if the plan provides for it, its analyses; it stops at the acceptance decision, which rests with the manufacturer.

What falls within incoming inspection

The useful scope is described by what the manufacturer must be able to justify to an auditor or a customer:

  • The identity of the delivery: supplier, product ordered, purchased item reference, quantity announced and quantity received, batch number.
  • Condition on delivery: integrity and cleanliness of the vehicle, packaging and pallets, absence of pests, continuity of the cold chain, against the temperature range written down for each material (example: 0 to +4 °C for chilled meat).
  • Documentary compliance of the batch: presence, current version and scope of the expected documents, and explicit linking of these documents to the batch delivered.
  • Characteristics that can be checked at the dock: appearance, colour, odour, texture, foreign bodies, net weight, condition of labelling.
  • Consistency of analysis results with the requirements defined for this raw material × supplier pair.
  • The acceptance decision, its reason, its author and its record.
  • Updating the supplier's approval status when goods-in reveals a recurring deviation.

In many plants, raw material incoming inspection is described in a single procedure but carried out by two different functions: purchasing physically receives, quality decides. This split works on one condition: the decision rule is written down and known to both. Goods-in quality inspection, in the everyday sense, refers to the sensory and physical part of this system. It is a subset of it, not a synonym.

What does not fall within it

  • Carrying out analyses: sampling, methods, laboratory accreditation, measurement uncertainties. The manufacturer orders the analyses and interprets the results; it does not perform them at the dock.
  • Release of the finished product and the decisions that follow from it.
  • Process control, the production environment and contact surfaces.
  • Management of stock, batches and their internal traceability in production, which begins after acceptance.
  • On-site supplier audits and the annual performance review, which use goods-in data without being the same thing.
  • Regulatory compliance of the finished product: labelling, claims, authorisations.

The regulatory foundation, in three points

No European regulation requires a form called “incoming inspection”. The obligations it rests on are found elsewhere, and they are enough to frame the method.

  • Regulation (EC) No 852/2004, Annex II, Chapter IX, point 1: a food business operator is not to accept raw materials or ingredients - or any other material used in processing - if they are known to be, or might reasonably be expected to be, contaminated to such an extent that the final product would be unfit for human consumption even after normal sorting, preparatory or processing procedures.
  • Regulation (EC) No 852/2004, Article 5: operators put in place, implement and maintain permanent procedures based on HACCP principles, with documents and records appropriate to the nature and size of the business.
  • Regulation (EC) No 178/2002, Article 17: responsibility for the compliance of the food lies with the operator, at all stages under its control, and it is for the operator to verify that compliance.

References consulted on 12 November 2026: Regulation (EC) No 852/2004 and Regulation (EC) No 178/2002.

How does a goods receipt work, step by step?

The five steps below assume a prerequisite: a standard that defines, for each raw material and each supplier, the expected documents, the checks to carry out and the acceptance thresholds. Without this standard, goods-in comes down to a series of improvised judgements. Building this standard is described on our quality control plan page.

Step 1 - Document check

Before unloading, check that the batch comes with what is expected: delivery note, current version of the technical data sheet, batch test report or certificate of analysis, valid certification certificate, declaration of compliance where applicable. Three points are checked systematically: the match between the delivery note and the order, the exact product reference (a technical sheet bearing a similar reference is not the right sheet), and the link between the documents and the batch delivered. An expired document, or one that cannot be linked to the batch, is a documentary non-conformity, not an administrative detail: it is precisely what the auditor will test first.

Step 2 - Sensory and physical check

It is carried out on a sample taken according to a written rule, not on “whatever is visible” when a pallet is opened. Criteria are limited to what can be observed at the dock: appearance, colour, odour, texture, homogeneity, presence of foreign bodies, net weight, condition of labelling, cleanliness of packaging. Two requirements make the check reproducible: written criteria (with a rating scale rather than a simple “compliant / non-compliant”) and numerical tolerances per material, for weight, appearance and temperature. Sampling itself follows the rules on our sampling plan page.

Step 3 - Test report review

A report is not read like an attachment: it is compared. First check that it covers the batch delivered (product, reference, batch number, sampling date, issue date, laboratory). Then check that the expected parameters are covered, with a method and limit of quantification compatible with the thresholds to compare against. A perfectly readable report that says nothing about a critical parameter does not allow a conclusion - it opens a request for further information, not an acceptance. The next section details this matching.

Step 4 - The acceptance decision

Four outcomes should be planned in advance, with their standard reason: acceptance, conditional acceptance (for example pending receipt of a missing document, with use blocked in the meantime), hold or quarantine (missing result, doubt over batch identity), rejection. The acceptance decision belongs to the quality teams; purchasing bears the commercial consequence and the laboratory provides the analytical reading. This responsibility must be written down in black and white in the procedure, with the title of the function that decides and the rule applicable in its absence.

Step 5 - The record

The goods receipt record must allow someone who was not there to reconstruct the decision: date and time, supplier, product and reference, batch number, quantity, attached documents, checks carried out and results, decision and reason, name and function of the decision-maker, any concession, physical destination of the batch (stock, quarantine, return). A record that does not link the decision to the batch is unusable at audit.

Which documents should you require from the supplier, and what does each trigger?

Each expected document must be associated with a decision, otherwise it piles up with no effect.

DocumentWhat it establishesCheckpoints at goods-inAssociated decision
Delivery note and accompanying documentsThe identity of the delivery: supplier, product, reference, quantity, batch, dateMatch with the order; legibility of the batch number; quantity announcedAcceptance of the physical delivery; in the event of a discrepancy, transport or supplier dispute
Product technical data sheetDeclared composition, allergens, characteristics and conditions of useCurrent version and date; reference identical to the one purchased; allergens consistent with the product fileDocumentary acceptance; outdated version = block or request for update within a written deadline, according to your procedure
Batch test report or certificate of analysisThe results obtained on the sample taken from the batch deliveredBatch identity, parameters covered, method, limit of quantification, unit, date, laboratoryAcceptance, hold or rejection depending on comparison with internal requirements
Certification certificate (IFS Food, BRCGS, ISO 22000, GlobalG.A.P.)The level of control of the supplier's system - not the quality of the batch deliveredValidity date at delivery, scope (site, product family), issuing bodyContinued approval; expiry passed = rule written in your procedure (example: approval suspended until the certificate is renewed)
Declaration of compliance (food contact materials, sector regulations)The declared regulatory compliance of the material or productMaterial reference, regulations covered, date, signatoryDocumentary acceptance; missing = block on the packaging concerned
Specific attestations (origin, non-GMO, allergen-free, customer requirement)A particular requirement of a customer or marketExact scope of the attestation; batch or period coveredAcceptance conditional on the attestation; otherwise written concession or rejection
Supplier questionnaire and approval fileThe supplier's ability to meet requirements, at the time of approvalCompleteness, attachments, date of last reviewSupplier approval status: approved, conditionally approved, suspended

This table settles two common confusions. A certification certificate covers a site and a range, not today's delivery: it governs supplier approval, not batch acceptance. And a declaration of compliance is read with the material number in hand, otherwise it proves nothing about what is delivered.

How do you match a test report against your internal requirements?

Matching is a mechanical operation, provided it is written down. It takes five points.

  1. Check the batch identity. Product, reference, batch number, sampling date, issue date, laboratory, signature. A compliant report for another batch is not valid for this one.
  2. Take the material's requirements grid. For each parameter: the applicable threshold (regulatory limit, customer specification, stricter internal threshold), the expected unit and the basis of expression. An internal threshold benefits from having two levels: warning and blocking.
  3. Align the bases of comparison. A result expressed on a dry basis and a threshold expressed on an as-is basis cannot be compared. The wording “not detected” and “< limit of quantification” do not mean “absent”: they are read in the light of the limits of detection and quantification. And a parameter missing from the report was not analysed: it is not a compliant result.
  4. Conclude with a status. Only four outcomes: compliant, alert (warning threshold exceeded), non-compliant (blocking threshold exceeded), to be determined (missing information or incompatible basis of comparison). A “to be determined” status is not a rejection: it is a request for further information or a confirmation analysis.
  5. Keep together the report, the grid applied and the status obtained, so that the reading remains the same six months later, even if a threshold has changed since.
CheckpointQuestion to settleCommon mistake
Batch identityDoes the report cover the batch delivered?Accepting a generic report or one valid for a period
Parameters coveredAre all required parameters present?Treating a missing parameter as a compliant result
Method and limit of quantificationIs the limit below the threshold?Comparing a result with a threshold it technically cannot measure
Unit and basis of expressionAre both values on the same basis?Comparing mg/kg with ppm “by eye”, or dry basis with as-is
Version of the regulatory thresholdIs the threshold the one in force on the date of analysis?Comparing with a residue or contaminant limit that has since changed
Measurement uncertaintyIs the result close to the threshold?Deciding on a borderline result without taking uncertainty into account

On these last two points, two readers of the same report can reach two different statuses if the comparison rule is not written down. This is what Tracklab's test report compliance calculation does: the platform extracts the results from the report, including “not detected”, compares them with your thresholds and the four European regulations it builds in and keeps up to date, and calculates a status per parameter. Each status keeps a trace of the threshold, regulation, its version and its date; the laboratory's conclusion remains displayed alongside. Tracklab calculates and traces: the acceptance decision remains that of the quality teams.

With Tracklab

Tracklab gathers reports from your suppliers and laboratories and calculates, parameter by parameter, their compliance status against your requirements and the regulations. Discover Tracklab's LIMS software, built for the manufacturer who receives analyses.

Report received: what status?After checking batch identity and bases of comparison
CompliantAll required parameters below the applicable threshold
Non-compliantBlocking threshold exceeded: rejection, return or traced concession
AlertWarning threshold exceeded: quality decision and closer monitoring
To be determinedMissing information or incompatible basis: request for further information or re-analysis, never acceptance by default
Batch identityParameters coveredLimit of quantificationUnit and basisThreshold version

Only four statuses, and five points to check before concluding. A parameter missing from the report was not analysed: it is not a compliant result.

What to do in the event of a concession or non-conformity at goods-in?

A non-conformity is a deviation found between what is delivered and what is required. A concession is the decision, taken knowingly, to use the material nonetheless - within a defined scope and under defined conditions. The two must be distinguished, because they do not involve the same people or lead to the same follow-up.

SituationWho decidesWhat must be tracedFollow-up
Non-conformity on a critical requirementQuality managementReason, quantity concerned, destination of the batchRejection or return; supplier complaint; review of supplier approval
Deviation on a non-critical requirementQuality with purchasingInternal concession: scope, quantity, duration, conditions of useCloser monitoring on subsequent deliveries
Missing or expired documentGoods-in qualityDocumentary block and request to the supplierBlock lifted on receipt of the expected document
Result to be determined or parameter not coveredQuality with the laboratoryRequest for further information and deadlineRe-analysis or rejection depending on production urgency
Deviation affecting a customer's contractual requirementQuality, with the customer's written agreementCustomer agreement, date, scopeConditional use; customer informed in the batch file

Three rules stop concessions becoming a habit: they are named and dated, they specify the quantity and batch concerned, and they are counted. The number of concessions per supplier is one of the clearest signals for revising a supplier approval or increasing a check frequency. An untraced concession amounts, in the event of a customer complaint, to an unjustified acceptance. The medium for recording it is detailed on our non-conformity report page.

What needs to be documented for the audit?

The auditor is not looking for a bulky file: they take a delivered batch and follow the thread back. What they must be able to find without help:

  • The incoming inspection procedure in its approved version, with its revision date and the functions that decide.
  • The requirements standard per raw material and per supplier: expected documents, checks, numerical internal thresholds, with their source and effective date.
  • Supplier documents received, dated and versioned, linked to the batch concerned.
  • Goods receipt records with decision, reason, author and signature.
  • Concessions and non-conformities, with the follow-up and closure time.
  • Rejections and returns, with a record of the supplier being informed.
  • Evidence of competence of the people carrying out sensory checks, and a description of the method used.
  • Retention periods for documents and records, set in writing and consistent with your customer requirements and the shelf life of your products.
With Tracklab

Tracklab collects test reports and certificates of analysis, calculates the compliance status of each parameter against your regulatory and internal standards, records the re-analysis and the request to the supplier on the report, and keeps every status change with its reason. Tracklab calculates and traces; it does not decide on the acceptance of a delivery.

For details of the points to check on a supplier certificate, see our article on the certificate of analysis.

Key takeaways

Incoming inspection rests on three written decisions: which documents and which checks for which material and which supplier, which comparison rule for test reports, and who decides on acceptance. Without them, goods-in produces records with no weight. Three actions let you move forward without heavy reorganisation: rework the requirements grid material by material, check that each expected document does trigger a decision, and test reconstructing a batch delivered six months ago. It is this test, more than the length of the procedure, that will tell you whether the system is readable.

On your own reports

To see the compliance calculation applied to your own test reports, book a meeting with the Tracklab team.

At a glance

The five steps of a goods receipt.

Each step builds on the previous one: the acceptance decision is only taken once the documents, the dock check and the reports have been checked.

  1. Document check

    Delivery note, technical sheet, batch report, certificates: present, current, linked to the batch.

  2. Sensory and physical check

    Appearance, odour, foreign bodies, net weight, labelling, according to a written sampling rule.

  3. Report review

    Batch identity, parameters covered, method and limit of quantification.

  4. Acceptance decision

    Acceptance, conditional, hold or rejection, with its reason.

  5. Record

    Enough to reconstruct the decision without having been there: batch, checks, decision, decision-maker.

Frequently asked questions

Incoming inspection: your questions.

Is incoming inspection mandatory?

No regulation requires a document with this name. However, Regulation (EC) No 852/2004 (Annex II, Chapter IX) prohibits accepting a raw material that the operator knows or may reasonably expect to be contaminated, and its Article 5 requires permanent procedures based on HACCP principles, with associated records. Regulation (EC) No 178/2002 (Article 17) places responsibility for compliance on the operator. Audit standards and customer specifications, for their part, require documented checks. In practice, incoming inspection is therefore expected everywhere, in varying formats.

Who decides on the acceptance of a raw material at goods-in?

The decision belongs to the quality teams, based on the checks carried out and the supplier's documents. Purchasing receives the goods, manages the supplier relationship and bears the commercial consequence of a rejection; the laboratory provides the analytical reading. What must be written down is the rule: who decides, on what criteria, and who decides in case of absence or urgency. A decision taken by default, for lack of a rule, is an untraceable decision.

Is a certificate of analysis needed for every delivery?

It depends on what the manufacturer has defined as a requirement for the material and the supplier, and on what its own customers require: there is no universal rule. What is constant is the reading rule: if a test report or certificate of analysis is required, it must cover the batch delivered and the expected parameters, with a limit of quantification compatible with the thresholds. Failing that, there are only two options: a request for further information, or an acceptance decision taken knowingly and traced on another basis.

Can a non-conforming raw material be accepted under concession?

Yes, provided the concession is a decision, not a workaround. It requires a written reason, a limited scope (batch, quantity, duration), the agreement of the authorised function, and the customer's written agreement when a contractual requirement is involved. The concession must also be followed up: repeated concessions for the same supplier feed into the supplier approval review and justify stepping up checks.

What to do when the report does not cover a required parameter?

Treat it as “to be determined”, never as compliant. Three outcomes: ask the supplier or the laboratory that produced the report for further information, have a re-analysis carried out on the batch on hold, or reject the delivery if the parameter is critical and the urgency is incompatible with waiting. In all cases, the decision and its reason are recorded with the batch, otherwise the absence of a result becomes, at audit, an absence of control.

Laboratory analyses module · demo on your data

Your reports compared right from goods-in?

Tracklab calculates the compliance status of each parameter in your test reports and certificates of analysis, and keeps a trace of the threshold applied. It does not decide on the acceptance of a delivery.

Our clients

Reliable supplier data, managed with Tracklab.

Their quality and purchasing teams collect, control and leverage their supplier data with Tracklab.

150+

companies supported

40,000+

suppliers referenced

90,000+

products and ingredients

Customer testimonial · Bouvard
“Tracklab has eliminated the blind spots that existed in our document monitoring. Every document is analysed, every change is detected and every decision is traceable. This has enabled us to take a real step forward in terms of professionalism and credibility, particularly with auditors and customers.”
EVEllen V.Quality Director, Bouvard Pro
CyberVadis
CyberVadis Excellence rating

Independent assessment of our cybersecurity framework and of the protection of the data entrusted to Tracklab.

They use Tracklab

  • Somapro
  • Jean Niel
  • La Fournée Dorée
  • Nautilus
  • Cérélia
  • Will&Co
  • Neta
  • Diffusions Aromatiques